Culotta & CulottaLLPAttorneys at Law
Jennifer Hinkebein Culotta, Founding Partner — Culotta & Culotta LLP
Founding Partner

Jennifer Hinkebein Culotta, Esq.

Founding Partner — Criminal Defense

Practice Focus
  • Criminal Defense
Direct812-913-6989

Practice

Jennifer has extensive trial and courtroom experience. In her three-plus decades as a litigator, she has tried more than 300 jury trials in state and federal courts, from both sides of the aisle. Jennifer has defended both individuals and corporations faced with huge criminal legal problems, locally, nationally and internationally.

In addition to her courtroom proficiency, Jennifer has assisted in several internal investigations in the United States and foreign countries.

Jennifer has been recognized for her capable litigation experience, she has appeared on TruTV (formerly Court TV) to provide legal commentary on the trial of State of Houston.

“In her three-plus decades as a litigator, she has tried more than 300 jury trials in state and federal courts, from both sides of the aisle.”

Representative Matters

Cases that have shaped this practice.

  1. Jennifer has the tenacity to investigate allegations and secure a federal dismissal of gun charges when justice dictated.

    United States v. Eady.

  2. After a 1½ year investigation into allegations of murder, Jennifer was able to effectuate the dismissal of two cases and the release of her clients who were falsely accused of murder (following dismissal), Culotta & Culotta filed a civil rights claim and successfully negotiated a large settlement for both clients.

    State v. Martin; State v. Guy.

  3. Ms. Culotta successfully secured a dismissal with prejudice of all rape charges against a man being held in jail in the State of Indiana.

    State v. Chalker.

  4. Even in the face of DNA evidence, medical evidence and a failed polygraph, Jennifer successfully defended to a Not Guilty Verdict a grandfather who was accused of molesting his granddaughter.

    State v. Askren.

  5. Ms. Culotta defended an individual falsely accused of Rape in the State of Indiana, just outside of Indianapolis. Ms. Culotta skillfully defended Mr. Howell in his jury trial, resulting in a Not Guilty Verdict as to all charges.

    State v. Howell.

  6. Again, understanding that an outright dismissal is better than a jury trial, Jennifer successfully negotiated the dismissal of all child molesting and criminal deviant conduct charges against a man being held in jail in the State of Indiana. Prior to Ms. Culotta's acceptance of representation, the client sat in jail for over three years, while former attorneys merely continued the case. Ms. Culotta, through a thorough forensic investigation, established the client's innocence with respect to the charges against him and secured a complete dismissal from the State of Indiana. Following dismissal, Culotta & Culotta filed a civil rights claim against the State of Indiana, and secured a large settlement for Mr. Woods.

    State v. Woods.

  7. Ms. Culotta served as the lead trial counsel successfully defending a Fortune Global 200 company in United States District Court in a wrongful termination claim brought by a corporate executive following a large-scale internal investigation, and successfully obtained a million-dollar jury verdict for the company on its cross-claim.

    Piratello v. Philips Electronics North America Corporation.

Credentials

The record behind the practice.

Education.

  1. J.D.

    1987

    Brandeis School of Law, University of Louisville

  2. B.A.

    1984

    University of Louisville, cum laude

Bar Admissions.

  • Indiana State Bar
  • Commonwealth of Kentucky Bar
  • Louisiana Bar
  • District of Columbia Bar
  • Federal District Courts in Indiana, Kentucky, and the District of Columbia

Memberships & Leadership.

  • President, Clark County Public Defender Board, 2014 – present

  • Member, Indiana Supreme Court Committee on Rules of Practice and Procedure, 2017 – 2025

  • National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers

  • Indiana Bar Association

  • Kentucky Bar Association

  • District of Columbia Bar Association

  • University of Louisville Association

Previous Experience.

  1. Partner at Hunton & Williams LLP, Washington, D.C.

  2. Executive Counsel to the Director of the Criminal Enforcement Program within the U.S. EPA, Washington, D.C.

  3. National Academy Instructor at the Federal Law Enforcement Training Center, Glynco, Georgia

  4. Homicide Special Prosecutor in the New Orleans District Attorney's office, Louisiana

Awards & Recognition.

  • Honor

    AV® Preeminent™ Rated Martindale-Hubbell

  • Honor

    National Association of Distinguished Counsel, Top One Percent

  • Honor

    Top 100 Criminal Defense Lawyers in Indiana, 2014, 2015

  • Honor

    Guest Commentator, TruTV (formerly Court TV)

  • Honor

    Top Defense Wins, The National Law Journal, 2002

  • Honor

    Recipient, EPA Award for Outstanding Legal and Policy Support in Complex Litigation Involving Recently Enacted Legislation Effecting Significant EPA Cases — 2000

  • Honor

    Recipient, EPA Award for Outstanding Service — 1999

  • Honor

    Recipient, EPA Bronze Medal for Commendable Service, United States Environmental Protection Agency, 1997

  • Honor

    Received, EPA "Outstanding" evaluations during every period of evaluation during years of hire

  • Honor

    Recipient, Jefferson Public Defenders Walker Award (outstanding representation of indigent offender) 1990

Contact Jennifer

Direct line 812-913-6989.

Firm: (812) 941-8886. 815 East Market Street, New Albany, IN 47150.

Free Initial Consultation

Tell us about your case.

We’ll listen, ask the right questions, and tell you straight where the matter stands — no obligation, no pressure.

Talk to an Attorney